Ping Identity
CE 87Enterprises running hybrid on-prem and cloud identity at real scale.
Every price below comes from the vendor's own page, checked on July 29, 2026, not from a sales deck. The trap in IAM is what the seat rate leaves out: contract minimums, per-identity billing and modules a vendor prices only on request.
Of the 12 platforms here, ten publish at least one price and the rest quote on request. Published workforce seats open at $2 a month, with a median of $5.50, verified July 29, 2026. What that seat rate hides is the floor beneath it: an annual contract minimum, a per-identity meter on some platforms, and privileged-access modules the per-user figure never shows.
Ranked by a transparency score: pricing transparency 60%, user satisfaction 40%. Capability is not scored. It is the condition grid below. Prices are read from vendor pricing pages and re-checked per product on the dates shown. ComparEdge sells no IAM software and takes no payment for placement. How the score is built.
Rows rank by transparency score, not by price. The price column places every platform on a single log scale, and the units underneath it differ: some prices are per seat, one is per identity, and the flat-platform figures do not translate into a per-user number at all. Read positions on the axis, not the raw prices.
Reading the console
Two rules shape this table. A blank cell means the capability did not appear in what the vendor documented on its own pages by the verification date, so treat it as a question to raise, not proof it lacks the feature. The axis also shows monthly figures only. Ping Identity quotes its customer-identity line by the year, apart from the workforce seat, and Clerk and Descope charge a flat monthly platform fee instead of a per-seat rate, so their markers sit off the per-user scale.
Scroll the console sideways to reach the remaining conditions.
The shortlist ranks by what the plan actually costs your team, not by list price. Flat plans are folded into a per-team number so they compare like for like. Only vendors rated 85 and up are eligible.
For 6 seats at $6 per seat, start with these
Ranked by monthly team cost, vendors rated 85 and up · Your ceiling for this team: $36 / mo
Ping Identity
CE 87Enterprises running hybrid on-prem and cloud identity at real scale.
Microsoft Entra ID
CE 91 free tierMicrosoft 365 shops that want identity to sit inside the tenant they already administer.
Each row expands to every tier and the date every price on it was last checked. Ranking runs on the transparency score, not on price or how well known the brand is.
Transparency scorePricing transparency 60%User satisfaction 40%
Microsoft 365 shops that want identity to sit inside the tenant they already administer. The entry tier ships free with the directory, and the paid P2 and Suite tiers layer on top, with the Suite assuming a P1 subscription underneath.
Critical gapThe steep learning curve for complex policy configurations requires significant administrative overhead.
Microsoft Entra ID: expert take
The Suite seat looks like the whole price, but it assumes a P1 subscription underneath, so the sticker is not the total. The paid tiers are also bundled into Microsoft 365 E3 and E5, so M365 shops may already own what they are pricing.
Where Microsoft Entra ID holds up
4.6CE scoreG2 4.5 · 909 reviewsCapterra 4.6Founded 2010Verified July 16, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Free | Free | Free |
| Microsoft Entra ID P1 | $6 | $6 |
| Microsoft Entra ID P2 | $9 | $9 |
| Microsoft Entra Suite | $12 | $12 |
| Microsoft Entra Internet Access | Not published | $5 |
| Microsoft Entra Private Access | Not published | $5 |
| Microsoft Entra ID Governance | Not published | $7 |
| Microsoft Entra Verified ID | $0 | Not published |
Enterprises running hybrid on-prem and cloud identity at real scale. Its workforce tiers carry a 5,000-user contract minimum, so the entry seat is a rate that starts at thousands of seats, not one.
Critical gapPingOne lacks feature parity with established on-premise PingFederate deployments.
Ping Identity: expert take
The $3 Essential workforce seat looks like the category's cheap end, but it carries a 5,000-user annual contract minimum, so it begins in six figures a year, not at $3. Customer Identity is priced apart at $35,000 to $50,000 a year per tier.
Where Ping Identity holds up
4.5CE scoreG2 4.4 · 112 reviewsCapterra 4.3Founded 2002Verified July 8, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Essential (Workforce) | $3 | Not published |
| Plus (Workforce) | $6 | Not published |
| Essential (Customer) | Not published | $35,000 |
| Plus (Customer) | Not published | $50,000 |
A zero-trust replacement for a legacy VPN, wired to the identity provider a team already runs. The $15 Home plan is flat but non-commercial, so business use starts at the per-seat Teams tier above it.
Critical gapThe architecture limits connectivity to services rather than direct device-to-device communication.
Twingate: expert take
The $15 Home plan reads like the cheap entry, but it is flat and non-commercial, so a business skips it. Paid commercial use starts at the per-seat Teams tier, and DNS filtering is a listed add-on with no price on the page.
Where Twingate holds up
4.8CE scoreG2 4.7 · 76 reviewsCapterra 4.8Founded 2019Verified July 16, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Starter | Free | Free |
| Home | $15 | $15 |
| Teams | $5 | $4.25 |
| Business | $10 | $8.50 |
| Enterprise | Contact sales | |
A shared credential and secrets vault a small team wants running with SSO and SCIM. The $19.95 Teams Starter Pack is flat for up to ten members, and the eleventh moves everyone onto the per-seat Business plan.
Critical gapThe platform lacks self-managed recovery requiring manual administrator intervention.
1Password Business: expert take
The $19.95 Teams Starter Pack looks flat and cheap, but it caps at ten members, and the eleventh moves the whole team onto the per-user Business plan at $7.99 a seat. Individual and Families intro rates are first-year only and renew higher.
Where 1Password Business holds up
4.7CE scoreG2 4.6 · 1,791 reviewsCapterra 4.8Founded 2005Verified July 8, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Individual | $3.99 | $2.99 |
| Families | $5.99 | $4.49 |
| Teams Starter Pack | Not published | $19.95 |
| Business | Not published | $7.99 |
| Enterprise | Contact sales | |
Drag-and-drop authentication flows a product team assembles without hand-coding each step. The free tier runs to 7,500 monthly active users, and the paid tiers bill by that active-user count and by tenant, so cost tracks logins, not headcount.
Critical gapUser data migration remains a non-trivial engineering effort for legacy systems.
Descope: expert take
The free tier runs to 7,500 monthly active users, then Pro and Growth bill by that active-user count and by monthly active tenants, not by seat. Cost tracks logins and customer count rather than headcount, and MAU overages move the bill.
Where Descope holds up
4.9CE scoreG2 4.8 · 86 reviewsCapterra 4.8Founded 2022Verified July 16, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Free Forever | Free | Free |
| Pro | $249 | $249 |
| Growth | $799 | $799 |
| Enterprise | Contact sales | |
A React or Next.js sign-up flow a developer wants live in an afternoon, not a login page built from scratch. The Pro plan is a flat platform fee, and the meter starts on monthly active users past the included band, not on seats.
Critical gapThe prebuilt UI architecture restricts deep customization on legacy codebases.
Clerk: expert take
Past the free band the meter runs on monthly active users, not on seats. The Pro plan is a flat $100 platform fee, but every enterprise SSO connection after the first adds a monthly charge, and SMS authentication bills per message.
Where Clerk holds up
4.9CE scoreG2 4.8 · 126 reviewsCapterra 4.7Founded 2020Verified July 8, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Hobby | Free | Free |
| Pro | $100 | $85 |
| Business | $300 | $250 |
| Enterprise | Contact sales | |
A WireGuard mesh a DevOps team drops between laptops, servers and cloud instances, keyed to existing SSO. Tagged infrastructure is the hidden meter: fifty resources are free, and the per-user price does not cover what runs past that.
Critical gapSubnet routing configuration frequently fails on specific legacy router hardware.
Tailscale: expert take
Tagged infrastructure is the meter hidden inside a per-user price: fifty tagged resources are free, then each bills on top, and ephemeral CI minutes are capped. There is no annual billing, so the listed monthly seat is the rate you actually pay.
Where Tailscale holds up
4.7CE scoreG2 4.6 · 31 reviewsCapterra 4.8Founded 2019Verified July 8, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Personal | Free | Free |
| Standard | $8 | Not published |
| Premium | $18 | Not published |
| Enterprise | Contact sales | |
Mid-market and enterprise teams past a handful of seats that want SSO across thousands of pre-built integrations. Its three self-serve tiers share one annual contract minimum, so the smallest teams pay that minimum rather than the per-seat rate.
Critical gapThe sign-on layer becomes a single point of failure during an Okta outage.
Okta: expert take
The $1,500 annual contract minimum sits under all three self-serve tiers, so the advertised $6 Starter seat is never the floor a small team pays. Customer Identity is a separate platform with a $3,000 monthly base, priced apart from the workforce seat.
Where Okta holds up
4.6CE scoreG2 4.5 · 1,226 reviewsCapterra 4.7Founded 2009Verified July 16, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Starter | $6 | $6 |
| Core Essentials | $14 | $14 |
| Essentials | $17 | $17 |
| Professional | Contact sales | |
| Enterprise | Contact sales | |
| Enterprise (Customer Identity Base Platform) | $3,000 | $3,000 |
Cloud-native SMBs replacing Active Directory with one console for identity, access and devices. The free tier stops at ten users, and the products bill separately until a negotiated platform bundle folds them together.
Critical gapNon-obvious UI pathways impede configuration of granular, complex administrative settings.
JumpCloud: expert take
The products bill separately, so a real deployment stacks device management, SSO and directory lines rather than one seat. The free tier stops at ten users, and the bundled Platform packages are negotiated, not listed, with Platform Essentials capped at 300 users.
Where JumpCloud holds up
4.6CE scoreG2 4.5 · 3,968 reviewsCapterra 4.7Verified July 8, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Free | Free | Free |
| Device Management | $11 | $9 |
| SSO | $13 | $11 |
| Device Identity Management | $15 | $13 |
| Platform Essentials | Contact sales | |
| Platform | Contact sales | |
| Platform Prime | Contact sales | |
Regulated enterprises that need privileged-access control and session recording, not just workforce SSO. The $2 Single Sign-On module is the cheapest published line in the category, but the privileged-access core it is really selling is quoted, not listed.
Critical gapRDP session monitoring causes significant input lag and visual degradation for remote administrators.
CyberArk: expert take
The $2 Single Sign-On module anchors the front page, but it is the loss leader, not the product. The privileged-access core CyberArk actually sells runs near $149 a user, quoted rather than listed, many times the modules on show.
Where CyberArk holds up
4.5CE scoreG2 4.4 · 71 reviewsCapterra 4.5Founded 1999Verified July 8, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Single Sign-On | $2 | Not published |
| Adaptive MFA | $3 | Not published |
| Identity Lifecycle Management | $4 | Not published |
| Workforce Password Management | $5 | Not published |
| Identity Compliance | $5 | Not published |
| CyberArk Identity | Contact sales | |
| Privilege Cloud | Contact sales | |
| Identity Security Platform | Contact sales | |
| Enterprise (Self-Hosted) | Contact sales | |
Large regulated enterprises above several thousand identities that need governed access certification. It licenses per identity rather than per seat, and its tiers are split by a workflow ceiling of 15, 50 or 200, a rare axis in this group.
Critical gapThe mandatory IQService server dependency increases deployment overhead for legacy infrastructure management.
SailPoint: expert take
Licensing counts identities, not seats, so contractors and machine identities land on the bill alongside employees. The three cloud tiers are separated by a workflow ceiling of 15, 50 or 200 automations, a rare axis, and every tier is quoted rather than listed.
Where SailPoint holds up
4.6CE scoreG2 4.5 · 174 reviewsVerified July 8, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Identity Security Cloud Standard | Contact sales | |
| Identity Security Cloud Business | Contact sales | |
| Identity Security Cloud Business Plus | Contact sales | |
| IdentityIQ (Self-Managed) | Contact sales | |
Phishing-resistant, device-bound credentials an enterprise adopts to retire SMS and TOTP codes. Every line is a twelve-month marketplace contract quoted on request, with no self-serve tier to test first.
Critical gapThe implementation process frequently exhibits software bugs during initial technical deployment.
Beyond Identity: expert take
Every line is a twelve-month AWS Marketplace contract quoted on request, with pricing capped around a thousand users before a private offer takes over. Part of the core is flagged as an add-on, and there is no self-serve tier to trial the platform first.
Where Beyond Identity holds up
4.5CE scoreG2 4.4 · 79 reviewsVerified July 16, 2026
| Plan | Monthly | Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Small Market Bundle | Contact sales | |
| Authentication Essentials | Contact sales | |
| Zero Trust Identity & Device | Contact sales | |
| Secure Access Complete | Contact sales | |
What the records say
Ping Identity starts cheaper: $3 / seat against $5 from Microsoft Entra ID, $2 apart at the door.
For 6 seats, Ping Identity bills $18 / mo and Microsoft Entra ID bills $30 / mo, $12 / mo between them.
Both carry 5 of the 5 capability columns on the record.
Users side with Microsoft Entra ID: 4.5 on G2 against 4.4 for Ping Identity.
Microsoft Entra ID runs a free tier to start on; Ping Identity does not.
Both publish every tier they sell.
Pick Microsoft Entra ID for: Microsoft 365 shops that want identity to sit inside the tenant they already administer.
Pick Ping Identity for: Enterprises running hybrid on-prem and cloud identity at real scale.
Microsoft Entra ID
CE 91 · G2 4.5Verified July 16, 2026
Ping Identity
CE 87 · G2 4.4Verified July 8, 2026
Both price lists on the category axis
Where they differ
Only Microsoft Entra ID has on the record
Only Ping Identity has on the record
—
The published seat is the smallest true number on almost none of these pages. Workforce platforms attach an annual contract minimum, so the per-seat rate only applies once you buy enough seats to clear the floor. Below that, you pay the floor. A five-person team and a fifty-person team can owe the same amount.
Then the unit shifts. Most of the 12 list a price somewhere, but that number can be per seat, per monthly active user, per identity or per tagged resource. Two per-user quotes are seldom the same purchase, which is why ranking this category on entry price alone tells you very little.
The advertised module is often not the product. A vendor can list a cheap single sign-on line on the front page while the privileged-access platform it actually sells is quoted privately and runs many times higher per user. The same pattern hides directory sync, governance and adaptive access behind an enterprise tier.
One more line rarely makes the pricing page: the suite you already own. A major cloud vendor bundles its identity tier into the productivity suites many buyers already pay for, so for those teams the cheapest IAM is a licence sitting unused in the tenant. Read the entry seat as a floor, not a total.
Identity pricing is a floor exercise: the advertised seat is real only above the contract minimum, and the minimum is the actual entry price. Multiply the seat by the smallest team the vendor will sign, then decide if the number still reads cheap.
Workforce and customer identity are different products with different meters, seats against active users. The ranking rewards vendors whose floors are printed where a buyer can find them.
Still weighing it? Answer 5 questions, take a shortlist.
How this review is made. Prices are read from vendor pricing pages and re-checked on the dates shown against each product. Condition columns reflect the feature set recorded on the vendor’s own pages on that date. ComparEdge sells no IAM software and takes no vendor payment for placement. Where a vendor publishes nothing, this page says so rather than estimating. Ranking is by transparency score: pricing transparency 60%, user satisfaction 40%. What a product can do is shown in the condition columns and carries no weight in the number.