The question that matters: “In what situation will I regret choosing A over B after 3 months?”
Scenario: Session Store With Sub-Millisecond Read
Redis
Session Store With Sub-Millisecond Read Latency
Redis stores user session data with consistent sub-millisecond GET operations, handling 100K+ requests per second with a single instance where a database session store would create a bottleneck.
MySQL
Read Replica Offloading for Reporting Queries
MySQL replication routes heavy analytical queries to a read replica, removing contention with write-heavy OLTP traffic and keeping application response times below 100ms during peak loads.
Redis Unique Strength
Rate Limiting via Redis Sliding Window Counter
Redis INCR with EXPIRE implements sliding window rate limiting in 2 lines of code, enforcing per-user API quotas without adding a separate rate limiting service.
→ Choose Redis if this scenario applies to you. MySQL doesn't offer a comparable solution.
Redis Unique Strength
Pub/Sub Fan-Out for Real-Time Notification Delivery
Redis Pub/Sub broadcasts events to thousands of connected subscribers in under 1ms, enabling real-time dashboards or notifications without polling the database.
→ Choose Redis if this scenario applies to you. MySQL doesn't offer a comparable solution.
MySQL Unique Strength
InnoDB Full-Text Search for In-App Search Features
MySQL's InnoDB full-text index supports natural language and boolean search queries on text columns without a separate Elasticsearch deployment for basic in-app search needs.
→ Choose MySQL if this scenario applies to you. Redis doesn't offer a comparable solution.
MySQL Unique Strength
ProxySQL Connection Pooling Against Connection Storms
ProxySQL in front of MySQL pools thousands of application connections into tens of database connections, preventing connection exhaustion on deployments that scale web processes horizontally.
→ Choose MySQL if this scenario applies to you. Redis doesn't offer a comparable solution.